112 North Main Street,
North Liberty IN 46554
574-656-3321
Welcome to Over The Top Bakery Cafe!
Located in downtown North Liberty and part of the Potato Creek Shops, Over The Top Bakery Cafe is a great destination to find all of your handmade baked good needs!
Looking for a nice meal as well? Look no further!
You'll find everything you need here and more.
Traditional baked goods, along with other options,
Dairy Free • No Gluten • Sugar Free
Made in a Non Designated Kitchen
We Offer Something For Everyone
Thanksgiving Orders
are now Closed, but we
will try to keep stocked
for Nov 26th!
CAFE
Weekly Specials Menu
OPEN
Wednesday - Friday
6AM to 4PM
Saturday
7:30AM to 3PM
Serving Breakfast 6AM to 3PM
Serving Lunch & Specials 11AM to 3PM
Current Specials 11/19 - 11/22
Wednesday
Loaded Baked Potatoes
$11.95 Choice of 3 w/ Butter+Sour Cream
$12.95 Choice of 5 w/Butter+Sour Cream
Choices: Pulled Pork, Nacho Cheese, Shredded Cheese. Broccoli, Bacon
Thursday
Classic Club with a Choice of Side
$10.95
Sides: Cottage Cheese, Apples+Dip, Chips+Pickle, or Pretzels+Pickle
Friday
Classic Panini with a Cup of Soup
$10.95
Saturday
Only Open and serving 7:30AM til 3PM
Spinach Bacon Quiche $8.29
Caramelized Onion and Squash Quiche $8.29
Served with a Fresh Fruit Cup (Strawberries, Blueberries, or Banana)
Stuffed French Toast (Banana, Strawberry, or Blueberry) $8.29
Soup of the Week: Cheeseburger, and Chicken + Noodle
Cup $3.50 Bowl $4.25
Give the Perfect Gift!
Daily
*Philly Cheesesteak $10.95
*Honey Mustard Chicken Swiss $10.95
Sausage, Egg, Cheese Breakfast Burrito $8.49
*1/3 lb Beef Hamburger $10.95
*Sweet Pulled Pork $9.95
*Italian Sub $10.95
*Chicken Bacon Ranch $10.95
Grilled Chicken Salad $10.59
Chicken Caesar Wrap $9.95
*All served on Fresh Baked Bread with a side of Chips
Upgrade to Side Salad for $1
CALL
(574) 656-3321
VISIT US
112 North Main Street
North Liberty, IN
Subscribe Here to Our Newsletter for
Weekly Specials & More!
CONTACT US
Over The Top Bakery Cafe © 2025 All Rights Reserved. Tara Ashlee Photo & Design