Decorative graphic that looks like pink dripping icing

112 North Main Street,

North Liberty IN 46554

574-656-3321

Photo of bakery staff inside bakery

Photo of Exterior of Over The Top Bakery Cafe in the evening showing the awning and interior lit up

Graphic that looks like tape

Graphic that looks like tape

Graphic that looks like tape

Graphic that looks like tape

Welcome to Over The Top Bakery Cafe!

Image of a whisk

Located in downtown North Liberty and part of the Potato Creek Shops, Over The Top Bakery Cafe is a great destination to find all of your handmade baked good needs!

Looking for a nice meal as well? Look no further!

You'll find everything you need here and more.

Traditional baked goods, along with other options,

Dairy Free • No Gluten • Sugar Free

Made in a Non Designated Kitchen

We Offer Something For Everyone

Dairy Free Icon

Sugar Free Icon

CLICK HERE TO SEE US IN THE NEWS!

Decorative Advertising Banner that says "Order Your Graduation Cakes Now! Click Here To Order"

Decorative Graphic that looks like a bakery exterior awning, this one is pink striped

CAFE

Weekly Specials Menu

OPEN
Wednesday - Friday

6AM to 4PM

Saturday

7:30AM to 3PM

Serving Breakfast 6AM to 3PM

Serving Lunch & Specials 11AM to 3PM

Decorative Graphic that looks like a bakery exterior awning, this one is pink striped

Decorative Graphic that looks like a bakery exterior awning, this one is pink striped

Current Specials 6/3 - 6/6

Award Image with a wreath outline and a star and fork at top, inside says 2023 Over The Top Bakery Cafe Best Cafe on Restaurant Guru

Wednesday

Classic Club

$10.95

Thursday

Amish Country Casserole

with Garlic Toast

$10.95

Friday

Classic Panini with a Cup of Soup

$10.95

National Donut Day!!

Buy a Drink & Get a Free Classic Donut

Saturday

Only Open and serving 7:30AM til 3PM

Spinach Bacon Quiche $8.29

Caramelized Onion and Squash Quiche $8.29

Eggs Benedict $8.59

with side of Apple Salad

Soup of the Week: Chicken n Rice, and Beef Vegetable Soup

Cup $3.50 Bowl $4.25

*1/3 lb Beef Hamburger $10.95

*Sweet Pulled Pork $9.95

*Italian Sub $10.95

Daily

*Philly Cheesesteak $10.95

*Honey Mustard Chicken Swiss $10.95

Sausage, Egg, Cheese Breakfast Burrito $8.49

*Chicken Bacon Ranch $10.95

Grilled Chicken Salad $10.59

Chicken Caesar Wrap $9.95

*All served on Fresh Baked Bread with a side of Chips

Upgrade to Side Salad for $1

Give the Perfect Gift!

Purchase a gift card for yourself

or one for a friend!

CLICK HERE

JOB OPPORTUNITIES

CALL

(574) 656-3321

E-MAIL

VISIT US

112 North Main Street

North Liberty, IN

overthetopbakerycafe@gmail.com

Subscribe Here to Our Newsletter for

Weekly Specials & More!

CONTACT US

Over The Top Bakery Cafe © 2026 All Rights Reserved. Moon Storm Creative