112 North Main Street,

North Liberty IN 46554


The Bakery

Ask The Decorator


Decorated Sugar Cookies

Start at $1.00 each, and go up depending on design.

Available Flavors

Chocolate Chip

Peanut Butter,

Oatmeal Raisin,

Snicker doodle,


Lemon Sugar,

Amish Sugar

6 Cookies for


12 Cookies for


12pk Frozen Cookies

Ready to Bake

(not available in all flavors)






Holiday Cookie Decorating Kits

Are Also Available Seasonally for Holidays



Custom Cookies are Also Available!

Call or Contact Us for Pricing.

Over The Top Bakery Cafe © 2024 All Rights Reserved. Tara Ashlee Photo & Design