112 North Main Street,

North Liberty IN 46554


The Cafe


Classic Panini*


Ham & Cheese, Turkey & Swiss,

or Grilled Cheese     $6.29




Hamburger, Pulled Pork,

Cheese, and Bacon     $13.49




1/3 Pound

Never Frozen Beef Patty on a
Fresh Baked Bun

Grilled to order     $9.19

+ Cheese .50

+ Deluxe (Tomato, Lettuce, Mayo) .75




BLT     $10.95

Pulled Pork     $9.49

Italian Sub     $8.95

Chicken Bacon Ranch     $10.29

Philly Cheesesteak     $11.49

Honey Mustard Chicken Swiss     $10.29



*Comes with a side of Kettle Chips or Pretzels. Upgrade Chips to a Side Salad for $1.00

Deluxe Panini*


Reuben, Muffeletta, or

Cubana     $9.95


Mushroom & Swiss Burger


Hamburger topped with

Swiss cheese and Slathered with

Mushrooms     $10.49




Changes Weekly

Cup     $3.50

Bowl     $4.25




Mixed Greens topped with

Shredded Cheese, Tomatoes,

Handmade Croutons, and your

choice of our made in house;

Ranch, Russian, and

Maple Balsamic Vinegar

Large     $6.25

Small     $4.95

+ Ham or Turkey $1.50


Grilled Chicken Salad     $9.59

Over The Top Bakery Cafe © 2023 All Rights Reserved. Tara Ashlee Photo & Design